Web 2.0 for the College Search
Friday, January 30th, 2009Dear Babs,
My daughter has been doing her college search on peer-review sites and I’m concerned. Is that really the best way to search for college? It seems like it’s more of a soapbox for discontented students than a source of accurate college info. Shouldn’t she be looking up official stats?
-2.0 Sceptic
—
Dear Sceptic,
You’re right to be concerned if your daughter’s only source of information about college is from college student reviews. However, you shouldn’t entirely discount them either.
Student reviews of college can be helpful in that they give potential applicants an idea of what real students who attend that particular school think about their education. Especially in cases where the high school student does not know many students at that college, or the college is far away, student reviews can give him or her a first-hand look at what their life might be like if they go there. Of course student reviews are biased-they’re personal opinions! But hopefully your daughter will read many, many reviews before making up her mind about a college. One poor review of a class, facility, or program should not dissuade her. However, if everyone complains about a lack of computers in the lab, terrible food, or overpriced athletics fees, it is something to take into consideration.
Let me ask you this: if your daughter was doing a report on El Salvador, would you tell her to only read one “official” book? Or would you have her read encyclopaedia articles from different sources, biographies of its important dignitaries, and many different historical studies of major events?
The college search is no different than doing a report on school. The more info she can get from the most sources, the more knowledgeable she will be. Online college info from peer-review sources is just one piece of the puzzle. On CampusCompare, college profiles include official statements from the colleges, statistics from the Board of Education, AND college student reviews. By reading up on all aspects of a college, not just “official” statements, your daughter is more likely to make an informed decision about her future.
Good Luck!
Babs

















