School Safety vs. Student Rights
Thursday, June 19th, 2008Where should we draw the line between school safety and a student’s right to privacy?
More and more schools are asking professors to watch out for students who could potentially pose a threat to campus safety and security.
After the shootings at Virginia Tech, the creative writing faculty put out a guide to help professors identify and respond to student’s fictional work on violence, murder and suicide. The University of New Mexico has also created a hot line to take calls from profs who have concerns about students’ writing that contains “credible threats of harm to self and others.” Similarly, Boston University has published a brochure, “Helping Students in Distress,” that advises faculty to watch for writing with themes of “hopelessness, social isolation, rage or despair.”
If a student looks ‘suspicious’ schools are even checking out their personal Facebook or MySpace page to see if there are signs of dangerous behavior.
But are these tactics ethical?
Do these measure infringe on a student’s right to privacy? And do they find a student guilty before they have committed a crime? In an age where everyone has a blog (including myself) do schools have the right to access this information?
Psychologists warn that it is very difficult to predict future violence. So is it right to come down on students who write crime or violent fiction? In fact, college students can have an active imagination and might not realize the implications of their words.
Also, is it fair to ask professors to scope out ‘dangerous’ students.? They certainly have not been trained to assess a work for signs of a troubled mind.
So what do you think, are student rights worth being stepped in the name of campus safety and security?







