College Application Tips You Don’t Expect: Part 2
Wednesday, November 18th, 2009It’s time to stop recycling the same-old admissions advice and start breaking out of the box. Last week we talked about the age-old adage “be yourself” and whether it has a place in college applications. This week, we tackle the admissions essay and the hoopla that surrounds it. It may be unexpected application advice, but by the time we’re done with it, your 5 paragraphs are going to be a piece of cake.
Quit Stressing About Your Essay: It’s easy to put all your energy into your admissions essay. By the time senior year rolls around, there’s not a lot you can do about your SAT scores or your GPA. So putting all your efforts into the one part of your application that you still have some control over is tempting. But if you’re putting off other things-like studying for your midterms and getting those recommendation letters-you’re doing yourself a disservice.
Contrary to popular opinion, college admissions departments frequently do not rate the essay as highly as they do your class rank and test scores. There are of course exceptions, especially among small liberal arts colleges like Hampshire College and Sarah Lawrence College. But for the most part, your admissions essay is a secondary part of your application. Large colleges just don’t have the time to go over every applicant’s essay with a fine tooth comb. Another reason why they tend to undervalue the admissions essay is that it is a subjective measure of a student’s capabilities. Colleges look for applicants who will do well in their college and go on to do well in the job-market. Your GPA and SAT scores are statistically-proven predictors of your future success, your essay is not. Of course there are plenty of bright students who just underachieved in high school, but unfortunately, many colleges do not want to make that gamble.
It’s hard to hear, but if you’re praying for a brilliant essay to rescue you from rejection, you may be out of luck. An admissions essay is not going to resurrect your application if everything is sub-par. It’s important to try and write a good coherent essay, but putting all your energy into crafting a “brilliant essay” will not save you. You may even unintentionally detract from other parts of your application by focusing too much on the essay. Do your best, get someone else to proofread it and make comments, and write a second draft. Beyond that, and you could just be wasting your time.
















